44 low data
Homestay
1.0(1)
Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.
Beachfront & Island HomestayHomestay
Shamrock Seaview 11 Beach Villa
Beachfront & Island HomestayFamily & Large Group HomestayHomestay
2 Google reviews
- Services
- Beachfront & Island Homestay, Family & Large Group Homestay, Homestay
- Reviews
- 2
What recent reviews say
Both guests reported serious maintenance problems: broken lights, leaking kitchen tap, non-working water heater and hair dryer, poor WiFi, and dirty utensils. Review evidence is limited to two one-star assessments both citing the need for better upkeep and cleanliness.
Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.
Watch-outs
- broken lights and appliances
- leaking taps and plumbing faults
- poor cleaning and hygiene
- weak WiFi
- inadequate furnishings and amenities
poor-maintenanceunhygienicpoor-wifi
Think twice if: Guests concerned about maintenance standards and cleanliness should reconsider; recent stays reported broken appliances and poor hygiene.
Worth knowing
- Bathroom and hall lights faulty
- Kitchen tap leaking
- Water heater non-functional
- Hair dryer non-functional
- Utensils unwashed or unclean
- WiFi connection poor
How it compares
- Rated 1 against a 4.51 average across the 3860 beachfront & island homestay businesses listed here.
- Has more Google reviews than 31% of the businesses in this directory.
How we scored this
How We Score Star rating 50
Review volume 21
Review recency 66
Review sentiment 33
Profile completeness 25
Verification 0
Rating breakdown
5
0
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
2
Similar homestays nearby
55 low data
Shamrock Boutique Villa
3.9(62)✓ Google-verified
The beachfront location and space attract group bookings, but guests encounter serious maintenance failures: broken TVs, non-working air conditioning, missing WiFi, and visible wear. Owner communication is slow and dismissive of problems. The most damaging issue is misleading room counts in listings, leading to booking cancellations.
Private Pool Villa HomestayBeachfront & Island HomestayFamily & Large Group Homestay
61 low data
Penang Island Lodge – Ocean 25 Shamrock Beach
5.0(3)✓ Google-verified
Three five-star reviews on a limited sample. Guests note the property's scale and roomy layout near Shamrock Beach, though security is unsupervised. Only three reviews available; limited detail on specific services or drawbacks.
Beachfront & Island HomestayGuest HouseHomestay